The 6 Best Medicine Cabinets
The 6 Best Medicine Cabinets
A good shower curtain liner is one of those things you don’t think about until you have a bad one. A flimsy, cheap liner that billows in and sticks to you mid-shower is the worst. And then there’s the mildew that seems to appear overnight, or the puddle of water on the floor because it just isn’t doing its one job.
I’ve spent years just grabbing whatever was cheapest at the store, and I finally got tired of it. A liner might seem like a small detail, but the right one can keep your bathroom cleaner, drier, and just feel a little more pleasant to be in.
So I went on a mission to find the best bathroom shower liners out there. I looked for ones that are heavy enough to stay put, easy to clean, and built to last more than a few months. These are the ones that actually hold up in my family’s busy bathrooms.

This liner costs $14.99, and it’s been my go-to for our main bathroom. You can feel the quality right out of the package. The 8G EVA material is thick and heavy, so it hangs straight and doesn’t fly around.
I really appreciate the rust-resistant grommets, which haven’t shown any signs of wear after two seasons in a steamy bathroom. It does a fantastic job of keeping every drop of water in the tub, which is exactly what I need.
The Downside: It’s not mildew-proof, so you do have to give it a good wipe-down with a cleaner every couple of weeks to keep it looking fresh.

At $14.99, this is the liner I put in our guest bath, which has terrible ventilation. The biggest selling point for me was the mildew-resistant treatment, and it really works. I’ve had this up for months and it still looks brand new.
I also loved that it had zero chemical smell when I opened it. The magnets at the bottom are strong and do a great job of holding the liner against the tub wall.
The Downside: The magnets are almost too strong and can sometimes make it a little tricky to pull the curtain back without a good tug.

For $15.99, this liner is a workhorse. It’s what I use in the kids’ bathroom because it’s durable and I don’t have to worry about it. It just plain works.
The PEVA material is eco-friendly and tough, and the reinforced header has held up to my kids yanking it open and closed. It effectively contains all their splashing, which is no small feat.
The Downside: It’s completely clear, which offers absolutely no privacy. That’s fine for the kids’ bath, but not ideal for our master bathroom.

Okay, at $42, this is definitely a splurge. But it’s so stylish that you can use it as a standalone curtain. We have the olive one in our master bath and it makes the whole space feel more designed and intentional.
It’s made from a high-quality, non-toxic EVA that hangs beautifully and doesn’t have that off-gassing smell. It feels substantial and is surprisingly quiet when you move it.
The Downside: The price is obviously the biggest drawback. It’s a lot to spend on a liner, even a really nice one.
This liner is $20. I’m a big fan of fabric liners because they just feel softer and more luxurious than plastic. This one gives our bathroom a hotel-like feel, and it drapes much better than plastic ever could.
The polyester fabric is treated to repel water, and it works really well. My favorite part is that I can just toss it in the washing machine when it needs a refresh. No more scrubbing by hand.
The Downside: It needs to be machine washed to get truly clean, which is more involved than a quick spray-and-wipe on a plastic liner.
Priced at $25, this is another great fabric option, especially if you want some color. With 23 different color choices, it’s easy to find one that matches your bathroom decor. We got a dark grey one and it really pulled the room together.
It’s machine washable and the texture looks much more expensive than it is. The fabric also helps dampen the sound of the shower spray, which is a nice little bonus.
The Downside: I’ve seen some reviews mention that the brighter colors might fade a bit after many washes, though I haven’t experienced that myself.
For around $30, the snap-in system on this liner is brilliant. I can’t stand having to undo all the shower hooks just to take the liner down for cleaning. With this, the fabric liner just snaps off the main curtain.
This makes cleaning so incredibly easy. The waffle weave fabric looks very high-end and the weighted hem keeps it in place. It’s the perfect blend of style and convenience.
The Downside: The plastic snaps are the main point of failure. I do wonder how they’ll hold up to years of snapping and unsnapping.
For me, it comes down to a few things. First is the material. I like the heavy feel of a thick EVA or PEVA liner because they don’t billow. But for looks, a machine-washable polyester fabric liner can’t be beat.
Weight is also important. I always look for a liner with magnets or a weighted hem. This is non-negotiable. It’s the only way to guarantee it hangs straight and doesn’t attack you in the shower.
Finally, I think about cleaning. If you’re okay with wiping a liner down regularly, plastic is fine. If you’d rather just throw something in the laundry once a month, go with a fabric one. Either way, choosing a quality liner makes a bigger difference than you’d think.
The 6 Best Medicine Cabinets
The 10 Best Drain Cleaners for Every Clogged Sink in Your Home
The 6 Best Medicine Cabinets for a Clutter-Free Bathroom
The 5 Best Towel Warmers
Leave a Reply